Sunday, July 11, 2010

Sharia Law faculty, Kabul University: Girl Power!


I got to meet the director again who called in the younger (Who did not give me a card--I'll get his name later) to translate. This is the third time I have met him and he is less intimidating now that I have gotten to know him a bit. For some reason the first time I met him I had the impression that he was a giant but now he is just a bit taller than me.

the director had concerns about the sample. He said that you can't tell about a country from taking the soil from one place. I said that sometimes you can tell a lot about a river from just one glass of the water. He said that there are many rivers in this case. I was going to point out that there is only one river in Kabul but thought it better to pass. He seems to like using metaphors. we had one go round last year about learning about Islam from a waiter versus and expert.

The young professor took us to a class and I was quite surprised to find that it was an all girls' class. Mirwais had said that last year the girls were enthusiastic about the survey while the boys last year were initially suspicious. I certain found that the girls in this third year class were not shy about giving their opinions (what Afghans are?), but that they also made rather sharp and cogent arguments. Again, I found that people gave small speeches rather than engage in a shorter give and take. I don't know if this is a broader characteristic of the culture or just something that happens in academic settings though I my sense is that it is the former. Unfortunately it was apparently not "OK" to take pictures.

One young lady said that the human rights groups are always criticizing Afghanistan, saying, for instance, that we should not kill a murderer because it is a violation of human rights. But isn't endangering the community by letting a murderer go violating the human rights of the community as well as the victim?

Another young woman made an intriguing point about the NGOs and women's rights. I am not sure that I fully got her point, but she was critical of the women's rights NGOs. She made two points. First, that by constantly talking about "women's rights" rather than human rights, they create the sense that their is some set of rights that are peculiar to women and, by being specific to women, somehow inferior to general human rights. Second, she argued that by talking about the special rights of women they undermined the family. These two points seemed to me to be somewhat contradictory but I didn't really have the chance to probe the issue very deeply.

There does seem to be a tension in the Western Intellectual world that has not really been faced straightforwardly in that we talk about multiculturalism (treating all cultures as equal) and a universal set of human rights as if those two propositions were completely compatible if not interchangeable. But what if individuals in a culture does not want the rights we classify as universal? We can sometimes dismiss the refusal or some rights as being a product of ignorance or fear, but that hardly seems a tenable answer in the case of these rather impressive young women. Indeed, the young women in the Islamic Law class had more cogent arguments and every bit as much confidence as the rather more loquacious young men in the economics department.

The younger member of the Sharia Law faculty who had been charged with shepherding us around proved to be quite talkative once we were alone. In the presence of the Department chair he had been quite deferential, not venturing to give his own opinions. When we got a chance to talk to him alone he was very interesting. One thing that struck me was that as conservative as they are he hated the Taliban. Two things he mentioned stand out.

He had a friend at an NGO. She worked in Afghanistan for a few years but as the Taliban's terrorism got more and more extreme her movements were more and more restricted. He said that near the end she would send him emails asking him to come visit her in her 'prison'. Like most of the foreigners in Afghanistan she was being picked up in a dark-windowed SUV and kept in a "guest house" with the same NGO types. There is a list of 11 restaurants they can go to. Luckily for me I am expendable and can go wherever I want.

The other thing he mentioned was a student that he had in class. Something came up where they had to give the students a couple of days off. This student was so happy because he would have time to go back to his village and fight with the Taliban for a few days, doing his duty of Jihad. The professor was shocked that he had someone in his class that thought like this and that would declare it openly.

I asked him if he was afraid of the Taliban. I said that he was a conservative Muslim with a beard and a Pashtun, so he would be safe right? He looked at me as if he were dealing with a particularly slow child……

14 comments:

Olverafmtx said...

Taking Action Against Texting And Driving Jays Releases New Adaptable Headphones Triple.fi 10vi, Expensive Headphones with S Denon AH-D7100 Music ManiacTM Over-Ear Headphones, Silver Details. The need to stay safe and within the law when using your vehicle should be your top priority.

Anonymous said...

i think eat fruit may be the greatest.:D

Stop by my web page; best way to build muscle mass and lose fat

Anonymous said...

Right. Rather than complaining about and trying to control other people's behavior, it seems like the easiest point to do would be to just block them from your feed. We can only control our own behavior.

Feel free to surf to my homepage ... attract women using subliminal seduction techniques

Anonymous said...

Though it's nice to get fast results, I find the healthiest way is to just brush your tooth with toothpaste that has baking soda in it. I've learned from
a friend that baking soda is supposed to whiten your teeth,
though it doesn't do anything health wise. That's why using toothpaste WITH the
stuff in it is the healthiest way to go about it. Just twice
a day, or if you're really dedicated, every time after a meal, for 2 minutes each.

my webpage teeth Whitening swabs

Anonymous said...

Ok, if all Supes has to do is wait for Hulk to change again to banner, then each of the Hulk has to do is find some kryptonite, correct?
Let's hold it even. I dn't remember the Hulk currently
being a killer either. Neither the Hulk nor Superman has ever
truly used their complete power, if they did everyone they fought will be deceased.


Also visit my web blog: superman stamina review full

Anonymous said...

What is best really dnpeeds on what you want to produce, but right here is my list:
- Bit and brace for auguring out holes for tennons.
- Very good rip noticed.- Very good crosscut noticed.
- Good miter noticed.- Bench chisel.- Mortise chisel.
- Tri-square.- Bench with vise, benchdogs, and stops.
- Jack plane.- Cabinet scraper.Check out Roy Underhill's Woodwright's Shop textbooks and PBS series.
He is all hand tool.

Take a look at my weblog: arrow hamlet 10' x 8' shed instructions

Anonymous said...

Be sure you acquire the audiobook

My web page - precision nutrition pdf

Anonymous said...

This site was... how do I say it? Relevant!! Finally I've found something which helped me. Cheers!

my web-site - office furniture outlet corona

Anonymous said...

i m in search of ladies in uae for discreet connection

Visit my blog ... female mind mastery by marcus London

Anonymous said...

nicely bob clearly you do not work out extremely significantly but
no-explode operates miracles for me it gets me amped up for
my workout thats the caffeine and it provides me a good pump for the duration of my exercise thats the NO maybe you should try working out harder maybe thats why it doesn't perform

my web-site ... six pack shortcuts download mike

Anonymous said...

with the way college students find out now and how easily
they are distracted, it truly is far better for them to find out inside
a way? that's disguised as entertainment. the crucial thing is the fact that the college students are getting the information required to become in a position to grow. it should not create a difference in what ways the knowledge is gained. if using ipads and this kind of are promoting their schooling, that it what matters.

Look at my webpage; 100 ways to attract women

Anonymous said...

Wow, great submit just for the meals. I'm a follower of Martin's web site but in no
way followed this one till this collaboration. Martin's site is great but doesn't have a lot of recipes.


Here is my web blog - precision nutrition lean eating program for women

Anonymous said...

Hello! I simply would like to offer you a big thumbs up for your excellent information you've got here on this post. I'll be returning to your web site for more soon.



Here is my blog - squirting orgasm mastery tori black

Anonymous said...

e cigarette, electronic cigarettes, e cigarette health, electronic cigarettes, e cigarette, best electronic cigarettes